I remember a few things about our teacher, Mrs. Tall: she was not at all tall, she was quite short. She was very sweet. And she was very positive about me, perhaps because by that time my mother was active either in the PTA or maybe even the school board. Mrs. Tall must have appreciated my Mother’s dedication to education.
But from that whole school year only one memory comes back and it is embarrassing to remember.
Mrs. Tall was quizzing the kids about what day of the week comes after the next one. And the kids had run out of answers to the tricky question of what comes after Wednesday. Nobody could come up with it, so Mrs. Tall said, “Jon knows.” And she turned to me to dazzle the class but I had no idea. So I semi-mumbled the classic kid excuse, “I know but I forgot.”
And I knew that every kid knew that that was a lie. Looking back with the wisdom of seven decades I realize that a better approach would have been to give a big smile, shrug, and say “I don’t know!” I could have bought my way out with humor but that wisdom was not available at that time.
Thinking back, I also feel bad for Mrs. Tall, who shared some of my shame. Of course, she learned not to use my very shaky genius to impress the class.
It is telling that that is the only memory that pops up for that school year.
But I do think were was a growing sense of identity for “our” class, as opposed to the “other” class, since there were two second grade classes. And to me, it became clear very soon that the other class was different, there were subtle differences in behavior, in identity that made me feel loyal to our class and a bit negative and untrusting of the “other” class.
And these classes were random divisions, not based on skill or on anything at all. Yet I was still able to develop a notable prejudice against the other class and its inhabitants.
This sense of different identities continued through 3rd, 4th, 5th, and 6th grades, with the personality of each teacher tending to color the culture of the class. Or at least how I perceived the culture of each class. If I felt iffy about the teacher I tended to feel iffy about the whole class.
This was a lesson in how easy it is to divide people and begin to set them against each other. All of this went away after 7th grade when all sorts of other factors became more important in how I saw other kids.